The dedicated faculty of St. Michael School is comprised of one principal, nine full-time teachers, and three part-time teachers. The nine full-time teachers are certified within the state of Pennsylvania. Teachers hold either a master's degree or Level II instructional certification and regularly attend programs of higher education. The faculty also participates in the diocesan Master Catechist Program.

• Mrs. Rhonda Seymour, Principal                                         rhonda.seymour@st-michael-school.org
• Mrs. Viki Krug, Secretary                                                     vkrug@st-michael-school.org
• Mrs. Amy Dietrich, Kindergarten                                          aoberholtzer@st-michael-school.org
• Mrs. Marjorie Frank, First Grade                                          mfrank@st-michael-school.org
• Mrs. Emily George, Second Grade                                      egeorge@st-michael-school.org
• Mrs. Susan Stevens, Third Grade                                        sstevens@st-michael-school.org
• Mrs. Leigh Ann Terndrup, Fourth Grade                               lterndrup@st-michael-school.org
• Miss Ashley Schreyer, Fifth Grade                                       aschreyer@st-michael-school.org
• Miss Sarah Steinbugl, Sixth Grade                                      ssteinbugl@st-michael-school.org
• Mrs. Gabbi Lechak, Seventh Grade                                     glechak@st-michael-school.org
• Mrs. Melissa Grata, Eighth Grade                                        mgrata@st-michael-school.org​
• Mrs. Nadine Toth, Art                                                             ntoth@st-michael-school.org​
• Sr. Augustine Marie Molnar, 6th-7th-8th Grades Religion     sraugustinemarie@st-michael-school.org
• Mrs. Becky Seymour, Lead Cafeteria Worker                       rseymour@st-michael-school.org
• Ms. Hannah Snyder, Cafeteria Assistant
• Mr. Logan Dietrich, Custodian